Other Mommy vs. Incidents Around the House: Book-to-Movie Breakdown

Josh Malerman’s 2024 novel Incidents Around the House is a masterclass in claustrophobic, child’s-eye dread, while Rob Savage’s October 2026 film adaptation Other Mommy turns that creeping psychological nightmare into a visceral, visually loud theatrical thriller. While both center on eight-year-old Bela and a shapeshifting entity begging to enter her heart, the movie streamlines the novel’s sprawling road-trip structure, cuts several major characters and set pieces, and completely reverses the book’s devastating ending.
Plot Summaries
The Book: Incidents Around the House (2024)
Told entirely in the first-person, stream-of-consciousness voice of eight-year-old Bela, Malerman’s novel follows the Martin family in Chaps, Michigan. Bela lives with her loving, playful father Russ ("Daddo") and her emotionally distant mother Ursula ("Mommy"), whose marriage is quietly fracturing under the weight of an affair. For years, Bela has been visited at night by a creature emerging from her closet that she calls "Other Mommy." At first, Bela treats it like a secret friend—until the entity grows impatient and escalates its nightly question: "Can I go into your heart?"
Once Ursula witnesses the entity impersonating her in Bela’s bedroom, the family goes on the run—staying with neighbors, retreating to Grandma Ruth’s house, hiding out in the home of Ursula’s lover Frank Doherty (after Other Mommy murders him as a "present" for Bela), and sleeping in gas station parking lots. Desperate to banish the creature, Russ hires a cynical paranormal investigator, installs security cameras, and turns to a local spiritualist named Lois Anthony. Lois theorizes that Other Mommy is drawn to Bela’s childlike purity and suggests shattering her innocence by revealing painful family truths. The strategy backfires horribly: Bela decides adults are liars, pretends the monster is gone, and returns home—where Other Mommy murders Grandma Ruth, Ursula, and Russ, leaving a terrified, lonely Bela to finally say "yes."
The Movie: Other Mommy (2026)
Directed by Rob Savage (Host, The Boogeyman) and starring Jessica Chastain as Ursula, Jay Duplass as Russ, and Arabella Olivia Clark as Bela, Other Mommy keeps the core premise intact while reshaping it for the big screen. Chastain pulls double duty, portraying both Bela’s conflicted mother and the uncanny doppelgänger version of Ursula that stalks the family.
As the entity’s attacks turn violent—culminating in a bloody confrontation at Frank’s high-security home and a disastrous séance led by Lois’s spiritual circle—the Martins realize they cannot outrun it. Instead of fleeing to the wilderness, the family returns to their own house to make a final stand. Trapped in the basement, Other Mommy forces Ursula to confess her affair, Bela’s true paternity, and her resentment toward motherhood. Heartbroken, Bela lures the entity upstairs by pretending to surrender. When Other Mommy approaches wearing Bela’s own face, Bela uses Grandma Ruth’s advice about trust, rejects the creature outright, and tears it apart saving her family, though leaving behind a lingering chill over their fractured marriage.
How They Are Similar
Bela’s Perspective as the Emotional Anchor: Even without first-person prose, Savage’s direction keeps the camera locked close to Bela’s eye level, ensuring the audience experiences adult arguments, whispered secrets, and domestic tension through a child’s confusion.
The Core Rules of the Entity: In both versions, Other Mommy is bound by a strict rule—it cannot simply take Bela’s body; Bela must willingly invite it inside her heart. Its powers rely heavily on mimicry, imitating loved ones (especially Ursula) to weaponize Bela’s need for affection.
The Family’s Fractured Foundation: Both stories root the supernatural horror in real domestic rot. Ursula’s extramarital affair with Frank Doherty and her ambivalence toward motherhood aren't mere subplots—they are the exact cracks Other Mommy exploits to isolate Bela.
Key Set Pieces: Several standout scares make the leap from page to screen, including the unsettling kitchen confrontation, the playground incident where Other Mommy mimics Bela’s friend Deb, the murder of Frank Doherty, and the ill-fated séance with Lois.
Major Differences and What Was Cut from the Book
Story Element | Incidents Around the House | Other Mommy |
Grandma Ruth's Fate | Murdered by Other Mommy, who stuffs her body in the foyer closet and wears her face to trick Bela. | Survives; she leaves to find help and her earlier lesson on trust becomes the key to Bela’s victory. |
How the Secret Comes Out | Ursula and Russ voluntarily tell Bela about the affair and her biological father during a camping trip at Lake Michigan. | Other Mommy corners the family in their basement and forces Ursula to confess her secrets in front of Bela. |
The Entity's Visuals | Deliberately vague and shifting—described mostly through shadows, unnatural proportions, and stolen faces. | Highly tactile and CGI-heavy, featuring glittery gold residue, skin-tearing gore, and Chastain’s uncanny physical performance. |
The Ending | Bleak: Bela’s parents are killed, she says "yes," and she is trapped in an empty void while the entity practices her voice. | Bittersweet Survival: Bela tricks and destroys the entity; the family survives, though Ursula remains visibly unhappy at Christmas. |
Parts of the Book Left Out of the Movie
To keep the runtime tight at around 90 minutes, the adaptation cuts or condenses several major stretches of Malerman’s novel:
The Lake Michigan Camping Trip: One of the book’s most unsettling third-act sequences—where Lois convinces the family to camp by Lake Michigan so Bela can spot Other Mommy lurking in the distance as a distorted dog-like shape while her parents confess their secrets—is completely cut.
Brian the Paranormal Investigator: In the book, Russ hires a self-serving investigator named Brian alongside guard dogs and a full home security grid. Brian witnesses Other Mommy, punches Russ in a fit of selfish euphoria over proving the supernatural exists, and abandons the family. The movie skips this subplot entirely, funneling all supernatural investigation through Lois’s group.
The Exhausting Nomad Phase: Malerman spends dozens of pages trapping the family in a relentless cycle of temporary shelters—fleeing to neighbors Dan and Amanda’s house, hiding out in a motel/relative’s home (Evelyn’s), and sleeping inside their car in a gas station parking lot. The film compresses this road-trip paranoia so the third act can return to the main house.
Kelvin the Babysitter’s Mimicry: While teenage babysitter Kelvin appears briefly in the film, the novel uses him much more heavily as a trusted figure whose voice and likeness Other Mommy steals to lure Bela out of hiding.
The Metaphor of the "Rooms in Your Heart": Grandma Ruth’s extended conversations teaching Bela to visualize her heart as a house with locked rooms—a central motif in the prose—are trimmed down to a brief thematic takeaway.
Which Version Hits Harder?
Other Mommy succeeds as a showcase for Jessica Chastain and Rob Savage’s talent for sharp jump scares, turning an abstract bogeyman into a tangible cinematic threat. However, by softening the ending into a standard survival victory and swapping slow-burn psychological isolation for flashy special effects, the movie loses the gut-punch tragedy that made Incidents Around the House one of 2024’s most talked-about horror novels. Readers who loved the movie’s creepy setup will find a much darker, more unforgiving nightmare waiting on the page.





Comments